10 Incredible Plush Finds That Turned Into Huge Profits
As a lifelong toy collector and reseller, I'm always on the hunt for hidden gems that can turn a tidy profit. And let me tell you, the thrill of the hunt is what keeps me going! Over the years, I've stumbled upon some truly incredible plush finds that have blown me away.
In this post, I'm excited to share my top 10 plush scores that ended up being major money-makers. From a $1,000 Roger Rabbit doll to a massive 5-foot tiger plush, these are the kinds of finds that make all the time and effort worth it. So get ready to be amazed - these are the biggest plush scores I've ever come across!
10. $40 Vintage Chuck E. Cheese Plush
Let's start off with a classic - the Chuck E. Cheese Pizza Time Theater Jasper plush. I found this little guy at a flea market for just $1, and knew I had a real winner on my hands. These vintage Chuck E. Cheese plushies from the 80s can be pretty tough to come by these days, and they tend to sell for a pretty penny.
After doing a bit of research, I discovered that this Jasper plush could fetch anywhere from $35 to $45 on the resale market. Not bad for a $1 investment, right? I was thrilled to add this to my growing collection of retro toy finds.
9. $70-$90 Big Comfy Couch Doll
Next up is a doll that I stumbled upon at a thrift store - the Lunette doll from the classic 90s kids' show, The Big Comfy Couch. Now, the original Lunette dolls from the show can sell for a pretty decent amount, around $40-$60. But this particular doll was in fantastic condition, and I knew I could get a premium price for it.
After some more research, I determined that this Lunette doll could sell for anywhere between $70-$90! That's a huge return on my initial thrift store investment. I always love finding rare and sought-after dolls like this one. It's such a thrill to uncover hidden gems that can turn a big profit.
8. $40-$60 Grateful Dead Plush
Speaking of hidden gems, check out this Liquid Blue 12-inch Grateful Dead bear that I found at a thrift store. Now, Grateful Dead merchandise has always been pretty popular with collectors, and their plush bears are no exception. This particular bear should sell for around $60.
But that's not all - I actually found two Grateful Dead bears at that same thrift store visit. The other one was a smaller 8-inch version, which typically sells for around $40. So in total, that thrift store trip netted me nearly $100 worth of Grateful Dead plush! You really do have to keep your eyes peeled, because sometimes there's more than one valuable item hiding in the same spot.
7. $150+ Vintage Nintendo & Pokemon Plush
Nintendo and Pokemon merchandise has always been a goldmine for toy collectors and resellers. And I hit the jackpot when I stumbled upon some vintage Nintendo Yoshi beanies at a thrift store. These original Yoshi beanie plushies from the 90s can sell for over $150 each!
I actually found three of these Yoshi beanies during that trip, plus a Poliwhirl plush that was hiding behind them. While the green Yoshi doesn't fetch quite as much as the other color variations, I still knew I had to snatch them all up. Nintendo and Pokemon plush from the 90s and early 2000s are always in high demand, so I couldn't pass up this amazing find.
6. $94 Giant Fish Plush
Sometimes, you just have to take a chance on an unusual-looking plush, even if you're not sure exactly what it is. That's exactly what I did when I came across this giant fish plush at a thrift store. It was a pretty big and bulky item, but something about it caught my eye.
After doing a bit of research, I discovered that this plush was actually worth around $94! It just goes to show that you can't judge a book by its cover (or a plush by its appearance). I took a risk on this one, and it paid off big time. You never know what kind of hidden gems you might uncover if you're willing to think outside the box a little bit.
5. $100+ Talking South Park Plush
Speaking of unexpected finds, check out this early 2000s talking Butters plush from South Park. I stumbled upon this gem at a thrift store, and I have to admit - I was a bit skeptical at first. South Park merchandise can be hit or miss when it comes to resale value, and I wasn't sure if this particular plush would be worth much.
Boy, was I wrong. After doing some research, I discovered that this talking Butters plush can actually sell for over $100! The fact that it was in perfect working condition definitely added to its value. I was blown away by how much this unassuming little plush was worth. It just goes to show that you can't always judge a toy's value by its appearance or brand.
4. $20-$30 Vintage Disney & Hanna-Barbera Plush
One of my most memorable plush scores came from an estate sale at a stranger's house. It was a sweltering 120 degrees in the attic, but that didn't stop me from digging through the piles of vintage toys and plush. And let me tell you, I hit the jackpot.
I was able to snag a ton of 70s and 80s plushies, including some really cool Disney and Hanna-Barbera characters. Most of these plush were only worth around $20-$30 each, but the sheer volume of them made it an incredible find. I even stumbled upon a rare Splash Mountain bear that I had to do some extra research on.
Estate sales can be a bit of a gamble, but when you hit the jackpot like I did, it makes all the effort and sweat worth it. I came away from that sale with a treasure trove of vintage plush that I knew would sell quickly and for a nice profit.
3. $200+ Giant Tiger Plush
Now, this next plush find is one that really blew me away. I was browsing the aisles of a thrift store when I came across this absolutely massive tiger plush. I'm talking over 5 feet long - it was huge! And the best part? I only paid $8.49 for it.
After doing some research, I discovered that this life-size tiger plush could actually sell for a couple hundred dollars or more! I've never seen a plush this big before, so I knew I had to snatch it up. It's the kind of unique, eye-catching item that collectors and plush enthusiasts go crazy for.
I can't wait to see how much this giant tiger ends up selling for. It's definitely one of the most impressive plush scores I've ever come across. Sometimes, the biggest risks lead to the biggest rewards!
2. $30 Rainbow Brite Plush
Next up is a Rainbow Brite plush that I found at a thrift store for the low, low price of $3.49. Now, I knew Rainbow Brite was a pretty popular character, so I had a feeling this plush might be worth something. But I was not prepared for just how much it would end up selling for.
You see, I had recently sold a harder plastic version of this Rainbow Brite Starlight plush for a whopping $375! I was hoping this softer, plush version would fetch a similar price. Unfortunately, it ended up only selling for around $30. Still a great return on my investment, but nowhere near as much as that previous Rainbow Brite find.
Even so, I'm always on the lookout for rare and vintage Rainbow Brite merchandise. The brand has such a devoted fanbase, and collectors are always willing to pay top dollar for the hard-to-find items. This plush may not have been a grand slam, but it was still a solid hit.
1. $1,000 Roger Rabbit Plush
And now, the moment you've all been waiting for - my biggest plush score ever. I recently found a brand new, never-opened Roger Rabbit plush that ended up selling for over $1,000! Can you believe it?
It all started when I found a used Roger Rabbit plush at a Savers thrift store for just $30. I knew that was a steal, so I quickly snatched it up and listed it on eBay. While trying to sell that used Roger Rabbit, I stumbled across an auction for a brand new, in-box version of the same plush. It was being sold by an auction house just a couple hours away, so I knew I had to go for it.
I ended up winning the auction and picking up the brand new Roger Rabbit plush. And let me tell you, it was in pristine condition - it even still had the original tag on it! I listed this mint-condition Roger Rabbit on eBay, and within a few weeks, it had sold for over $1,000. Can you believe that?!
This was hands down the biggest plush score I've ever come across. Finding a rare, vintage plush in perfect, never-opened condition is the holy grail for toy collectors and resellers like myself. I still can't believe I was able to turn a $30 thrift store find into a $1,000 payday. Talk about a life-changing score!
Conclusion
Well, there you have it - my top 10 biggest plush scores of all time. From a $1,000 Roger Rabbit to a massive 5-foot tiger plush, these finds just go to show that you never know what kind of hidden gems you might uncover when you're out thrifting and hunting for vintage toys.
As a lifelong collector and reseller, the thrill of the hunt is what keeps me going. I love the challenge of scouring thrift stores, estate sales, and flea markets in search of those rare and valuable plush that can turn a huge profit. And let me tell you, the payoff is always worth it when you stumble upon a score like these.
So if you're a fellow toy enthusiast, keep your eyes peeled and your mind open. You never know when the next big plush find might be waiting for you. Happy hunting!